Partner Visa Appeal

The Appeal Process

Partner Visa Refused: Appeal or Reapply?

After a partner visa refusal or cancellation, you generally face two paths: lodge an Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) review application within the non-extendable deadline, or reapply after refusal by lodging a fresh partner visa application instead. This page compares both options nationally on cost, time limit, evidence, and standing to apply, and explains when the Section 48 Bar can still affect a fresh onshore application after a partner visa refusal.

Both paths can be genuine options depending on the facts of a case, but they are not interchangeable, and choosing between them under time pressure is one of the more consequential decisions a refused or cancelled partner visa holder will make.

ART review Fresh application Section 48 Bar
Two diverging paths representing the choice between an ART appeal and a fresh visa application

The Two Paths After a Refusal or Cancellation

An ART review application asks the Tribunal to reconsider the Department's decision itself. Under Migration Act 1958 Part 5 Division 4 and the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024, the Tribunal conducts a de novo merits review, meaning it is not confined to the material the Department had when it made the original decision. The Tribunal can affirm the decision, vary it, or set it aside and either substitute its own decision or remit the matter to the Department for reconsideration.

A fresh application asks the Department to consider a new partner visa application from the beginning, assessed against the criteria current at the time of the new decision. It does not reopen or challenge the original refusal. The two paths lead to different decision-makers, different processes, and different practical constraints, summarised in the comparison below.

A road splitting into two paths, representing the choice between an appeal and a fresh application

ART Appeal vs Fresh Application at a Glance

FactorART review applicationFresh partner visa application
CostTribunal application fee of $3,727, with a 50% reduction available on financial hardship via the Request for Fee Reduction form (source: art.gov.au). This fee is separate from, and in addition to, any professional fee charged by a lawyer.Attracts its own separate visa application charge, set by the Department of Home Affairs. The current amount is published at immi.homeaffairs.gov.au. This is a Departmental charge, not a Tribunal fee, and is not quoted here.
Time limit28 days after notification of the decision if not in immigration detention, or 14 days if in detention, under section 347 of the Migration Act 1958. This deadline cannot be extended under any circumstances.No equivalent hard deadline applies to lodging a new application. Partner visas are generally exempt from the section 48 bar, but that exemption is generally understood not to apply where the applicant's most recent refusal was itself a partner visa refusal, which can still block a fresh onshore application in that circumstance.
What evidence carries overThe Tribunal's de novo review is not limited to the material the Department already had. Evidence already gathered for the original application, such as reg 1.15A/1.09A genuine-relationship evidence, generally remains relevant and can be supplemented with further evidence addressing the reasons for refusal.Evidence from the earlier application can generally be resubmitted, but the application is assessed afresh against current criteria. The gap identified in the Department's refusal reasons needs to be addressed again from the start, since the new application is a new decision, not a continuation of the old one.
Standing to applyOnshore refusal or cancellation (820/801): the visa applicant applies. Offshore first-stage refusal (309, sponsored): only the sponsor may apply, not the visa applicant, under section 347A of the Migration Act.Ordinarily made by the visa applicant, or lodged on the applicant's behalf for an offshore application, subject to the Section 48 Bar issue described below for an onshore applicant whose most recent refusal was itself a partner visa refusal.
Decision-makerAdministrative Review Tribunal, exercising the powers of the original decision-maker under Migration Act Part 5 Division 4 and the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024.Department of Home Affairs, considering the new application against the criteria current at the time of the new decision.

For the distinction on who can apply for review at all, see our Onshore vs Offshore Partner Visa Appeals page.

Standing: Who Is Actually Allowed to Apply

Open passport with immigration stamps, representing standing to apply for review

Standing to apply for ART review is not the same for every partner visa refusal. For an onshore refusal or cancellation of a subclass 820 or 801 visa, the visa applicant is generally the person who applies for review. For an offshore subclass 309 refusal, the position is different: only the sponsor may apply for ART review, not the visa applicant. This is a frequently misunderstood point, and it matters just as much to the appeal-or-reapply decision as it does to the appeal itself, since the same question can affect who is practically placed to pursue either path. Our Onshore vs Offshore Partner Visa Appeals page sets out this distinction, and its exceptions, in full.

The Section 48 Bar: A More Limited Risk Than It First Appears

Section 48 of the Migration Act 1958 can bar a person who has already had a visa refused or cancelled while in the migration zone from validly applying for most further visas while still in Australia. This is generally referred to as the Section 48 Bar. It does not prevent a person from lodging an ART review application against the original decision, since that is a review of the existing decision, not a new visa application.

Importantly, Partner visas (820/801) are generally among the visa classes prescribed as an exception to the Section 48 Bar under regulation 2.12 of the Migration Regulations 1994, so a fresh onshore partner visa application is not automatically blocked by section 48 in every case. However, that exception is generally understood not to protect a further onshore partner visa application where the applicant's most recent relevant refusal was itself a refusal of a partner visa, which is exactly the situation most visitors to this page are in. In that circumstance, section 48 may still validly bar a fresh onshore application.

Confirm your own visa history before choosing

Whether the partner visa exception to section 48 still protects your specific situation depends on a close reading of your visa history, including what your most recent refusal was actually for. Abandoning an ART review application in favour of a fresh application, only to find the fresh application cannot validly be made, can leave a person with no application on foot and no reviewable decision, particularly once the non-extendable ART deadline has passed. A paid consultation with one of our lawyers can confirm whether section 48, or its partner visa exception, applies to your matter before you commit to either path.

How to Decide

The question “should I appeal or apply again” does not have a single answer that fits every case, and this section sets out general considerations rather than advice about your specific circumstances. In most cases, the following factors are relevant to weighing an ART review application against a fresh application:

  • Strength of the original evidence. If the refusal turned on a gap that can be filled with better evidence of the same kind, for example more complete reg 1.15A/1.09A relationship evidence, an ART review application allows that evidence to be tested by a Tribunal that is not limited to what the Department already had.
  • Whether section 48 applies. If a fresh onshore application would not be validly accepted because of the Section 48 Bar, an ART review application may be the only available path, regardless of preference.
  • Time remaining against the deadline. Because the 28-day or 14-day ART deadline cannot be extended under any circumstances, a person close to that deadline generally needs to decide and act quickly, even if a fresh application also remains under consideration.
  • Standing to apply. For an offshore 309 refusal, only the sponsor can lodge an ART review application. Where the sponsor is unable or unwilling to do so, the options narrow further.
  • Whether the underlying relationship or sponsorship position has changed. A fresh application is assessed against current criteria, so a genuinely changed set of facts may be better suited to a new application than to a review of the old decision.

Because these factors interact, and because the Section 48 Bar in particular can eliminate an option that might otherwise look attractive, we generally recommend confirming your position in writing before deciding.

What Happens Next

If you are weighing an ART review application against a fresh application, the practical starting point is the same either way: confirm your deadline, confirm whether section 48 affects you, and confirm what standing you have to apply. Our free case assessment collects the facts needed to answer the first and third of these in writing. Where the Section 48 Bar question needs closer review of your visa history, that is addressed at a paid consultation, where one of our lawyers can advise on your specific circumstances rather than the general position described on this page.

Wooden blocks spelling consulting, representing the next step of a legal consultation

Frequently Asked Questions

Whether both are realistically available at once depends on your circumstances, including whether the Section 48 Bar affects a fresh onshore application in your case. This is a question best confirmed at a paid consultation rather than assumed either way.

Confirm your deadline before you decide

Start with a confidential case assessment so you understand which paths are actually open to you before the ART deadline passes.

Disclaimer

This page provides general information about choosing between an ART review application and a fresh partner visa application. It is not legal advice. Every case turns on its own facts, particularly where the Section 48 Bar may be involved, and the consequence of choosing the wrong path while a non-extendable deadline is running can be serious.