Why It Was Refused
Partner Visa Health and Character Refusal Appeals
A partner visa refusal or cancellation based on the character requirement under PIC 4001, or a health requirement under PIC 4005 or PIC 4007, is a separate ground from a genuine relationship refusal or a sponsorship limit refusal. It can still be challenged through an Administrative Review Tribunal review application, provided the strict lodgement deadline is met.
We represent applicants and sponsors whose partner visa application, or an existing partner visa, was refused or cancelled on health or character grounds. We work exclusively on Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) review applications for refused or cancelled Partner visas (subclasses 820, 801, 309, and 100), so a health or character refusal is assessed by our lawyers as a familiar and distinct category.

How this refusal differs from a relationship or sponsorship refusal
A partner visa can be refused or cancelled on several independent grounds, and a decision letter sometimes cites more than one. A refusal or cancellation under PIC 4001, PIC 4005, or PIC 4007 has nothing to do with whether the relationship itself was accepted as genuine, and nothing to do with how many partners a sponsor has previously sponsored. It is assessed on its own separate facts.
If your decision letter cites a health or character concern, the evidence that matters is different from the financial, household, social, and commitment evidence used to assess a genuine relationship, and different again from the sponsorship-history facts used to assess a sponsorship-limit refusal. Confirming exactly which criterion, or criteria, your letter relies on is the first step, because that determines what an ART review application needs to address.

The general structure of the health and character criteria
Health and character are assessed against separate criteria referred to as Public Interest Criteria (PIC) in the Migration Regulations 1994. What follows is a general structural description only, reviewed against Schedule 4 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (content reviewed 31 August 2026), and it does not quote or closely paraphrase the exact regulatory wording.
PIC 4001 (character)
Incorporates the character test. It generally directs a decision-maker to consider matters such as a substantial criminal record or other conduct that raises character concerns, within a discretionary character-assessment framework rather than a fixed medical threshold.
PIC 4005 (health, strict)
A health criterion applied strictly. It is generally understood to leave essentially no room for a waiver once the criterion is not met, which makes the underlying medical assessment itself the critical point.
PIC 4007 (health, waivable)
A different health criterion, generally understood to allow for a waiver. A waiver may generally be available where refusing the visa would not impose undue cost on the Australian community, or would not prejudice the access of an Australian citizen or permanent resident to health care or community services.
| PIC | What it broadly covers | Waiver generally available |
|---|---|---|
| PIC 4001 (character) | The character test; broadly, matters such as a substantial criminal record or other conduct that raises a character concern | Not a waiver in the health sense; addressed through a discretionary character-assessment framework |
| PIC 4005 (health, strict) | A health standard applied strictly | Generally understood as essentially unavailable |
| PIC 4007 (health, waivable) | A health standard applied with more flexibility | Generally available where refusal would not impose undue cost on the community, or prejudice access to health care or community services |
How an ART review can address a health or character refusal

Non-protection migration reviews before the ART are de novo merits reviews, meaning the Tribunal is not confined to the material the Department of Home Affairs had when it made the original decision. In a health or character refusal, this generally means the Tribunal can consider updated evidence directly relevant to how the applicable criterion should now be assessed.
For a PIC 4001 character refusal, this can generally include updated police clearances, evidence of rehabilitation or changed circumstances, and character references, tested against the character test's discretionary framework. For a PIC 4007 health refusal, this can generally include updated medical evidence and evidence bearing on whether a waiver should be exercised. For a PIC 4005 refusal, because a waiver is generally understood to be essentially unavailable, an ART review is more likely to focus on whether the underlying health criterion was correctly assessed on the medical evidence, rather than on persuading the Tribunal to exercise a discretion that does not generally exist for this criterion.
None of this describes a guaranteed result. The Tribunal must affirm the decision, vary it, or set it aside and either substitute its own decision or remit the matter to the Department for reconsideration, and which of these outcomes follows depends entirely on the evidence and facts of the individual case.
The same lodgement rules apply as for any other partner visa refusal or cancellation. A valid ART review application must be lodged within 28 days of notification if you are not in detention, or 14 days if you are, and this deadline cannot be extended under any circumstances. A health or character refusal does not receive a longer or more flexible timeframe, and the clock runs from deemed notification under sections 494B to 494C of the Migration Act 1958, not necessarily the date printed on the letter.
The ART review application carries the same government filing fee as any other Part 5 migration review: currently $3,727, with a 50 percent reduction available on financial hardship through the ART's Request for Fee Reduction form. This fee is set and published by the Tribunal itself, and it is separate from, and in addition to, any professional fee charged by our firm. Our own fee is fixed in advance on a fixed-fee basis, confirmed in a written fee agreement before work begins, with no hidden costs and payment plans available based on financial need.
What happens next
If your partner visa was refused, or your visa was cancelled, with a health or character concern cited in the decision letter, the practical next step is to identify precisely which criterion the letter relies on, and to check how many days remain under the non-extendable deadline. Our free case assessment is a written online screening built for exactly this purpose. It confirms, in writing, whether your matter appears to fall within a reviewable category and whether you are still within time, before any paid consultation is offered.

Frequently asked questions
A separate ground, still worth reviewing properly

A health or character refusal raises a different legal question from a relationship or sponsorship refusal, and it calls for a review application built around the evidence that matches the specific criterion involved. Start your free case assessment to find out, in writing, whether you are within the deadline and whether an ART review application is available to you.
Return to the homepage for an overview of our services, or start your free case assessment to check your deadline and eligibility.
Disclaimer
This page provides general information about the ART review process. It is not legal advice. Every case turns on its own facts, and this is especially true in health and character matters. Book a paid consultation to discuss your circumstances directly with one of our lawyers.